Why do People Make Parties on Purim?

The purpose of parties is to fulfill one of the important duties of the day: to publicize the miracle that Hashem performed for the Jews during the events of Purim. Hashem (G-d) turned around the day from anticipated tragedy to victory and joy, and saved all the Jews of the world from annihilation.

Parties are deeply rooted in the Tradition of Purim. Most of the significant events that took place in the Book of Esther happened at parties. King Achashverosh (Ahasueraus) made a party to celebrate the fact that Hashem had not rebuilt the Holy Temple. The Jews attended, and were thus liable for punishment.

But at that party, Hashem also made certain that events would take place that would eventually protect the Jews from their annihilation. At that party, the king had his wife killed, and this resulted in Queen Esther being appointed queen.

Twelve years later, Haman invited the king to a party, and there convinced him to kill all the Jews.

Three days after that, Queen Esther invited the king and Haman to two parties, at which she revealed that she was Jewish and that Haman’s decree would have her and her people killed.

Thus, making parties and drinking wine are strong reminders of the miracle that Hashem did for us.

We must remember that just as Hashem worked on our behalf behind the scenes, we must also keep a part of ourselves under control as well, even as we drink and be merry. We party to celebrate the miracle, not to act with wild abandon.

How is Purim celebrated?

Remember that in Judaism, the night always precedes the day, so every holiday begins the night before, and ends at nightfall the next day.

The night of Purim we read the Book of Esther in the synagogue immediately after the nighttime prayers. Each time the name of Haman (the bad guy) is mentioned, we make noises, stomp, yell, that sort of thing. We call this practice Klopping Haman — “Hitting Haman.” It is done to remember the commandment of “You shall blot out the name of Amalek.” (Haman was an Amalekite, and that was his real motive for hating Jews. It was an “inherited” racism.)

Afterwards, we go home and eat a festive meal. The custom today is to visit one’s Rabbis or anyone who has taught you Judaism lessons. In many places people (often students in a yeshivah) put on plays, usually funny plays, but not always. In general, the theme is fun and happiness. A lot of singing and dancing goes on, but it is forbidden to act wild or dangerous. This happiness is a requirement by Law, except for people who are, G-d forbid, in mourning.

The next morning, after the morning prayers, we read the Book of Esther again, doing the same thing at the evil Haman’s name. Afterwards, we eat a festive breakfast meal, and begin the day’s other observances. The day’s obligatory services constitute a number of things, including the giving of charity to at least two poor people. This is called Matanos lo’evyonim. It is a requirement and an obligation, and one of the Commandments we are required to fulfill on the day of Purim.

The Law, however, is that we should give to anyone who asks, and we pray that G-d do likewise to us, to give us whatever we ask just for asking. It is known that Purim is the best day for raising charity, because everyone gives what they can and often more.

Also among the day’s obligatory services is the requirement to give at least one friend two food items that are already prepared and are ready to be eaten. This is called Shalach Manos (though to be grammatically correct it should be called Mishlo’ach Manos, but few people bother with grammar these days, so never mind).

You can read about these in the Megillah, the Book of Esther, Chapter 9, verse 22: “…as the days on which the Jews gained relief from their enemies, and the month which had been transformed for them from one of sorrow to gladness, and from mourning to festivity. They were to observe them as days of feasting and gladness, and for sending delicacies to one another, and gifts to poor people.”

We celebrate by having joy and happiness. That’s why we make plays, that’s why we spend the day in never-ending singing and dancing, going around giving our friends and relatives baskets of goodies and sweets, dressing in costumes, cracking jokes, getting tipsy, giving charity, things like that.

The primary Festive Purim Meal is eaten in the late afternoon on Purim, after Minchah (the afternoon prayer). One must eat bread (washing as Jewish Law dictates), at least one cooked food, and drink at least one cup of wine. We call this the Purim Seudah.

The drinking of wine is significant, because many of the events of Purim happened through wine. Ahasueraus got drunk and killed Vashti, paving the way for Esther to be made queen. Esther gave wine to King Ahasueraus and lowered his defenses, which resulted in his killing Haman. Thus the Megillah tells us that we should celebrate by “feasting.” The Hebrew words for “feasting” means bread, cooked food, and drinking wine. The Talmud therefore tells us to drink on Purim “more wine than we usually do.”

During this meal, it is customary to begin the study of the Laws of Passover, which is just one month away.

The day before Purim, the Fast of Esther, we do not eat from morning until after hearing the Megillah at night, because of the fast that Esther ordained.

At the afternoon service before Purim it is customary to give three coins (preferably silver, and preferably coins with the number Ѕ on them) to charity in memory of the three “half-shekels” given to the Temple. In many synagogues the coins are provided as loans. We donate one-and-a-half dollars to the synagogue, to purchase the coins. We then pick up the silver coins so that we can take possession of them, and then donate them back to the synagogue. This is called Mach’tzis Hashekel, The “Half-Shekel.”

It is correct not to engage in business or go to work on Purim, if this is possible.

Before and during Purim we wish each other “ah fraylechin Purim” — a joyful Purim.

What is the Meaning of Purim?

A. Essentially, Purim is about how G-d is hidden in everything. G-d performs miracles for us, all behind the scenes.

The “official” story of Purim, as written for both the Persian royal archives of that time, and the Holy Torah, can be found in the Biblical Book of Esther. It would pay for you to read that Book. There’s a lot of information that is not stated openly in that Book, but the Prophets Mordechai and Esther managed to write it in such a way that it alludes to all the relevant information, and they recorded the explanations of their coded phrasing in the Talmud, which we still have today. These days you can find even English translations written by Rabbis, with the Rabbinic explanations on the bottom, just as can be found in the printed Hebrew texts.

It was during the time that the Jews were in Exile in Babylon, after the destruction of the first Holy Temple. Cyrus, king of Persia, had permitted the Jews to rebuild the Holy Temple. His usurper/successor, King Ahasueraus (Xerxes), put a halt to the rebuilding. He felt it would diminish his own power. He began to consolidate his kingdom, and when he was done with that he made an enormous party for all his subjects. He also exhibited the utensils from the Holy Temple and boasted about his own prowess. The Prophets and Sages declared it was forbidden to attend the party, because of this denigration of the Holy Temple Vessels, but most Jews attended it anyway, out of fear of the king. As a result, G-d decreed a warning against them as a reminder of their duties to G-d.

But G-d always prepares the cure before the hurt. At this party, the king got angry at Queen Vashti, and he had her killed. He searched for a new queen, and finally chose Hadassah, a Jewess. The Persians of the palace, however, called her Esther, after Ishtar/Astarte/Easter, who personified, to the Persians, beauty. What they did not know was that G-d had manipulated them in giving this nickname as well, for in Hebrew “Esther” means hidden. We shall soon see the significance of this name.

Then G-d created the punishment: Haman came to power. The king appointed Haman as viceroy. Haman decided to have all the Jews killed. It seemed to him and to many other people that it was all the fault of Mordechai, the righteous prophet who defied Haman’s laws. Haman, after all, wanted people to bow down to him. He hung a symbol of an idol around his neck, so that people would be bowing down to both. Jewish Law forbids bowing down in such a situation. One must rather accept death, before bowing down to anything idolatrous. Mordechai therefore refused to bow or kneel before Haman. Haman got very angry, and decided to kill all the Jews. (This is often cited as the classic case of anti-Semitism. Perhaps it is, but I think that ignores the real point.)

Haman declared his decree, but kept its exact nature secret. The public decree merely stated that everyone be prepared to fight and kill one nation on the 13th of Adar. The private decree sent only to the satraps and governors throughout the kingdom explicitly marked the Jews. Mordechai, through Divine Prophecy, found out about the details and informed all the Jews, and they began fasting and repenting. They acknowledged that they should have obeyed the Rabbis, and not attended the party, nor bowed down to Haman.

Because they repented, G-d’s decree against the Jews was annulled and reversed. Ahasueraus changed his mind about Haman, and killed Haman instead. The king’s change of heart seemed to come about because of Esther, who suddenly revealed she was also Jewish, and would therefore also be killed by Haman. The king got very angry at his favorite minister, and ordered him killed. The tree that Haman had prepared for Mordechai’s hanging was used instead to hang Haman.

Thus the turnabout nature of Purim. The reversal of the attitude of the Jews. The reversal of Ahasueraus’s mind and heart, at least to some degree. The reversal of the decree itself.

The decree: The 13th of Adar was to be the day that all the Gentiles were permitted to kill and despoil the Jews, and the Jews were forbidden to defend themselves. The king changed the nature of the decree only to the extent that the Jews were to be allowed to defend themselves. That change, along with the news that Haman had been hanged by the king, threw consternation into the hearts of the enemies of the Jews. Well, not all of them. Many still arose to kill the Jews on the 13th of Adar, but the Jews defended themselves and won the battle with great victory, though of course it would have been better never to have had to fight at all. Thus the day itself was reversed in intent and purpose.

Through it all, we see the hidden Hand of G-d, manipulating events from beginning to end. Many things were hidden and then revealed, such as Queen Esther’s nationality. The name Esther itself shows this, since in Hebrew “Esther” means “hidden.”

Esther’s original name was Hadassah, but she was called Esther by the Persians, because of her beauty. The name Esther was derived from the name Ishtar (a supposedly beautiful pagan goddess), which in itself originally derived from “Istahar,” a very bright star, and in some cultures, the moon.

Nothing happens by coincidence. For Esther was the bright star that the Jews needed in that time of darkness. For in Hebrew “Esther” means “hidden,” and the very lesson of Purim is that G-d is hidden in everything that happens. And from darkness, arose this morning star.

The whole lesson of Purim is that G-d also does things in a hidden way, but it is still G-d behind everything.

And that is the meaning of Purim.

The History of Chanukah

After the death of King Solomon, the kingdom of Israel got broken up into two kingdoms: Israel and Judah. Israel comprised the Ten Tribes, with Ephraim as their leader. The Kingdom of Judah consisted of the Tribes of Judah and Benjamin. (For more background on this and earlier periods in Jewish history, read my article on early Jewish History.

In Hebrew, Judah was called Yehudah, after the name of the Patriarch Yehudah (Judah). The people were called «Yehudim.» (Singular: Yehudi for a man, Yehudis for a woman.)

The Greeks, however, called Yehudah «Iudea.» When the Roman Empire eventually replaced the Greek Empire, they, too, conquered Iudea, as you know. In Latin, Iudea became Judea; Iudeans (Yehudim) became Judeans; and our religion came to be imprecisely known as «Judaism.» Eventually (I don’t know when), the term «Judean» was shortened to the now familiar «Jew.»

We start this story during the time of the First Holy Temple, built by King Solomon. Late in the First Temple era, the Assyrians came to power, and conquered many lands. They conquered the Kingdom of Israel, and exiled the Ten Tribes to far away lands. The Holy Temple was in the Kingdom of Yehudah, and so it was not touched. The Assyrians had the policy of moving conquered people from their native country to distant lands, as a method of controlling them. In place of the people of Israel, they moved people from the ancient land of Cutha into Samaria, a region in Israel. The location of the land of Cutha has long been forgotten, even by the Cutheans themselves. Now they call themselves Samaritans. The Samaritans hated the Yehudim, and caused them a great deal of trouble. Continue reading

The Meaning of Chanukah

And Other Questions People Have Asked Me.

chanukah question sign

Q. Why did the Sages institute the Holiday of Chanukah?

A. Well, we all know about the miracle of the lights, but that is not the real reason the Sages instituted the Holiday of Chanukah. The miracle of the lights is the reason the Sages instituted the lighting of the Chanukah Menorah lights, but the Miracle of the Lights teaches us something bigger than that.

Everyone agrees that there was some sort of victory. The Jews won something from the
Syrian-Greeks. The point of popular misconception is what exactly we won.

As you may have seen from reading my article The History of Chanukah, we won the right to live our own religious lives.

But how does the Menorah fit into that? Continue reading

Is Chanukah Jewish in Origin?

jewish with question

I often get this question:

Q. Wasn’t Chanukah created in imitation of the Gentile winter candle-lighting festival?

The answer is a most emphatic NO.

I did quite a lot of research about this, and I discovered that in the Middle East there were no cultures that had any winter festival of lights. Way up north, where the winter days are very short, some societies had festivals during which they lit ritual fires to in hopes that the daylight would return. But in the Middle East the winter days are not all that short. Thus, there were actually no such holidays in or near Israel at all. So there was no one to imitate.

The Zoroastrians did have a fire ritual, though it did not resemble Chanukah in any way.

The Talmud mentions that there was a Persian (or Parthian) pagan festival that sometimes coincided with Chanukah. Their law was that no one was allowed to light any lights at all at home during that festival. Lights were allowed only in their religious temples. Anyone who lit a light in their own home would be killed. It therefore makes no sense to assert that the Jews began to light candles in their own homes in imitation of the pagans. (And would they have risked their own lives to do it as well?)

Generally, the Jewish custom was to light the Chanukah Menorah at the window, to advertise to the world about the miracle that took place during Chanukah. (This is not obligatory, but a good thing to do.) But since during that pagan festival people were forbidden to have lights in their homes, it was dangerous for Jews to light their Menorahs in the windows. The later Mishnaic Rabbis therefore taught that when Chanukah coincides with the pagan holiday it is permitted to light the Chanukah secretly, where only the family can see it. (It was never really obligatory to put the Menorah in the window anyway.)

What is hard to understand is why people insist that Chanukah (or any Jewish Law) came from a Gentile festival. The Prophets and Rabbis, ever since the beginning of Judaism, from Moses to the Ultra-Orthodox Rabbis today, have vociferously condemned any borrowing of practices from Gentiles.

The Torah is full of such warnings. Moses warns us not to even study the practices of Gentiles: Continue reading

The Customs of Chanukah

and Their Meanings

Q. What Are Latkes And Why Do We Eat Them?

A. A latke is a sort of potato pancake.

One of the miracles of Chanukah occurred with olive oil. For this reason, the custom is to eat things made with oil. In America many people eat potato latkes, because that’s what most Europeans were able to make. In Israel, they eat sufganiot, donuts. I guess flour was easier for Israelis to get in the old days than potatoes.

Here’s a recipe for latkes. It’s pretty universal: Continue reading

The Courage of the Women

Channah and her Seven Sons

The times of the Greeks were terrible times. The stretched their hand out in overbearing might; they oppressed us, and they murdered us. They were not content to take our money, they wanted our very souls.

The Greeks forced upon us terrible things, the worst of which was idolatry. Idolatry, the worship of false gods, is the worst sin of Judaism. Worshiping idols is ripping out the very heart of Judaism from within oneself. But the Antiochus, king of the Greeks, wanted total control. If we did not obey him, and worship his idols, we were rebellious, and he felt that he had to kill us.

channah 7 sons

“The Martyrdom of the Maccabees”, Jean Baptiste Vignaly, 1781.

Antiochus considered himself a god too. Antiochus gave himself an additional name: Epiphanes, which means «god incarnate.» He wanted us to bow down to him and worship him like we worship Hashem. He placed images of himself all over the land, and forced Jews to bow down to these idols.

But most Jews refused to bow down to the idols of Antiochus. So Antiochus and his officers went on killing sprees. One day, he assembled all the people of a Jewish town, and showed them a Jewish woman who refused to bow down to his idol. This woman was named Channah (Hannah), and she had seven pure sons who also refused to bow down before the idol. The youngest of her sons was only seven years old. Continue reading

Lighting the Menorah

One of the purposes of Menorah lighting is to publicize the miracle to one’s family. Therefore, the entire family should be present during the Menorah lighting, including children old enough to watch.

If the entire household cannot be present at the lighting, they are nevertheless included in the lighting when one member is authorized to light on everyone’s behalf.

In order to increase the publicity of the miracle Hashem did for us, many people light the Menorah at the window (as was once the custom). Many people light the Menorah at the inner front door to their homes. They place it facing the Mezuzah, so that the entrance to their home is surrounded by Mitzvos (Commandments). But the truth is that anywhere the family can see it is acceptable.

Use a shammosh (a separate candle used to serve the others) to kindle the Chanukah Menorah lights. The shammosh has its special holder in the Menorah, and it should be above the other eight. Keep the shammosh burning also. Never use any Chanukah light to light anything else, even another Chanukah light. When necessary, use the shammosh.

The Chanukah Lights may not be used in any way, as they burn. We may especially not use them for light. Their purpose is to celebrate the miracles Hashem performed for our ancestors at this time of year. To remind us of this, we light an extra light, called a shammosh (attendant), which should be placed higher than the others.

The first night we light the light at the far right of the Menorah. The second night we add a new light to the left, the third night we add another light to the left of the first two, and so on, each night. After making the blessings, we light the leftmost light first, and then travel to the right, lighting as we go. So, on the eighth night, we place one candle (or oil and wick) in the holder at the right, then we place another one in the next holder, and keep on going to the left. Then we recite the blessings, and light the lights from left to right. So, the first one we prepare in the Menorah is the last one we light.

Anything that burns clearly without a smell is acceptable, however, olive oil is the most preferred, because the miracle took place with olive oil.

The flame of each light must be a small flame, like that of a single candle or oil light. The wicks should therefore not be a series of wicks plaited or held closely together, nor should they be very thick wicks.

One cannot fulfill the Commandment to light the Chanukah Menorah by using an electric Menorah. There are a number of reasons for this, but they involve a long, deep discussion of Jewish Law, and I’d like to keep this page easy reading.

The eight lights must all be at the same height, and should be placed in one straight line, with the shammosh a little higher. When looking straight at the Menorah, one should clearly be able to see that there are eight lights burning (or whatever number, for whatever night it is). The lights should not be arranged with some behind others.

If you cannot get hold of enough candles (or oil or wicks) to light each night, you may light just one each night, reciting all the same blessings first. The Rabbis instituted that we light at least one light each night of Chanukah to celebrate the miracle. However, the Rabbis also instituted that those who wish to perform the Commandment in the best possible way should light an extra light each night of Chanukah, so that on the eighth day we would be lighting eight days, and thus announcing how many days the miracle occurred. But the absolute necessary minimum is one light per night, and if you do it that way, you have fulfilled the basic Commandment.

If you miss one night, continue lighting the following nights the same number of lights the rest of the Jewish world is lighting.

The proper time to light is as soon as full night has arrived, as Jewish Law defines it (Halachic night). In North America, this is generally around 50 minutes after sunset. That is the proper and best time. Except in certain situations, like on Fridays (see below), one should not light before that time. Ideally, one should not light much later than that either, but if one could not light at that time, or one forgot to light on time, it is permissible to light the entire night (even a few minutes before dawn).

The lights must burn for at least half an hour. At least one half hour of burning must take place during the Halachic night. After the half hour is done, it is permitted to extinguish the lights, unless it is the Sabbath.

When you kindle the lights, there must be enough fuel in them to burn for the necessary time. If any of the lights accidentally burn out before the time has passed, it is not necessary to rekindle the lights.

When lighting on Friday evening, we cannot light once the Sabbath has started. So, we light just before lighting the Sabbath candles, which is 18 minutes before sunset. Therefore, the lights must have enough fuel (large candles, or lots of oil) to burn for at least 98 or more minutes. Why 98? It’s simple arithmetic: 18 minutes until sunset, 50 minutes until Halachic night begins, and another thirty minutes of required burning time during Halachic night. (18+50+30=98.)

Once the Sabbath is started, it is forbidden to light fires. If you missed lighting the Menorah and the Sabbath has already started, it is too late for that night. What you should do then is look for the lights lit in someone else’s window, or visit a Jewish friend who has lit a Menorah, and recite the second blessing (the one about the miracles).

On Saturday nights, the Sabbath must end completely (that is, it must be full Halachic night) before we may light the Chanukah Menorah. The Havdalah Ceremony is performed before the lighting of the Chanukah Menorah.

After lighting, women do no work (including cooking) during that first half hour. (Even if the lights burn longer, this law applies only for the first half hour.) This is the woman’s special holiday time, and does not apply to men. For the reason for this rule, see my page: The Courage of the Women.

It is forbidden to move the Menorah during that half hour of burning. This Law applies for only the first half hour, even if the lights burn longer. (Reminder: It is forbidden to move the Menorah throughout the entire Sabbath. Keep this in mind, if you have toddlers in the house. Always light the Menorah where children cannot reach it.)

The Lighting

Recite: I am hereby ready and prepared to fulfill the Commandment of Lighting the Chanukah Menorah.

Recite the blessings:

Boruch Attah Adonoy, Elohainu Melech ha-olam, asher kidishanu b’mitzvotav, v’tsivanu l’hadlik ner shel Chanukah.

(Blessed are You, Hashem our G-d, King of the universe, Who has made us holy through His commandments, and commanded us to light the Chanukah light.)

Boruch Attah Adonoy, Elohainu Melech ha-olam, she-asah nissim la’avosainu bayamim hahaim bazman hazeh.

(Blessed are You, Hashem our G-d, King of the universe, Who performed miracles for our ancestors in those days at this time.)

Only on the first night recite:

Boruch Attah Adonoy, Elohainu Melech ha-olam,
she-hecheyanu, vikiyamanu, vihigianu lazman hazeh.

(Blessed are You, Hashem our G-d, King of the universe, Who has kept us alive, sustained us, and brought us to this time.)

Light the first light. As you light the other lights (or on the first night, after you have finished lighting) recite or sing the following threnody:

We kindle these lights because of the miracles, the wonders, the salvations, and the victories that You, Hashem, did for our ancestors in this season, through the agency of Your holy Kohanim (Priests).

Throughout the eight days of Chanukah, these lights are holy, and we may not use them for anything. We may only look at them, to enrich the experience of thanking and praising Your holy and great Name for Your wonders and Your salvations.

Afterwards, we sing the following hymn to Hashem, called:

MAOZ TZUR:

Rock of Strength

O mighty stronghold of our salvation,

to praise You is a delight.

Restore our House of Prayer

and there we will bring a thanksgiving offering.

When You will have disposed of Israel’s enemies,

Then we shall complete, with a song of hymn,

the dedication of the Altar.

The soul of our people has been filled with troubles

our strength has ebbed from grief.

They embittered our lives with hardship

in this exile that is as bad as the exile in

Back then, Hashem brought forth His treasured people

with His great power,

and Pharaoh’s army, and all his offspring

went down like a stone in the deep waters.

To the Holy Temple Hashem then brought us.

But there, too, we had no rest for long.

An oppressor came and exiled us again

Because we had practiced foreign customs

and enjoyed forbidden acts that dulled our spiritual values.

But not long after we were exiled to Babylon

we returned with our leader Zerubabel;

after just seventy years of exile we were saved.

While we were in that exile,

Haman the Amalekite tried to destroy Mordechai and us.

Instead, it became a trap and a stumbling block for him

and his arrogance was put down.

You promoted the Benjamite, Mordechai;

You destroyed the name of the enemy

and he and his sons You hanged on the gallows.

During the time of the Second Temple,

Greeks gathered against us,

during the time of the Hasmoneans.

They breached the walls of our Holy Temple,

and they defiled all the oil jars.

And from one remnant of the flasks

a miracle was wrought for the Jews, the «roses.»

The men of wisdom established eight days

for song and jubilation.

Display Your holy might

and hasten the end of the exile, and give us salvation.

Avenge the death of Your servants,

whom the wicked nations have killed

The triumph has been too long delayed for us

and there seems to be no end to the days of evil

Repel those who would keep us in exile

and raise up for us the Seven Shepherds.

It is the custom among Hassidim to sit at the Menorah for the first half hour after lighting, studying Torah or singing Chanukah songs. Each moment we spend there is another moment fulfilling the Commandment of Chanukah Lights.

Shemini Atzeres: Extra Joy and Celebration

Shemini Atzeres (also known as Simchas Torah) is a day of joy. But what is it, and what do we do on it? Let’s look at its roots.

Immediately when the Holiday of Sukkos ends, the Yom Tov of Shemini Atzeres begins.

“Shemini Atzeres” means “the eighth day, a [day of] restraint.” Shemini Atzeres gets its name from the Torah itself, which says,

The 15th of this seventh month shall be the festival of Sukkoth to God, [lasting] seven days. The first day shall be a sacred holiday when you may not do any mundane work. For seven days you shall present a fire offering to God. The eighth day is a sacred holiday to you, when you shall bring a fire offering to God. It is a time of restraint when you may do no mundane work.

– Leviticus 23:34-36

The actual term “Shemini Atzeres” is taken from another verse: “Day eight, a restraint it shall be for you, you shall do no mundane work” (Numbers 29:35). Of course, in English, that is better said as “The eighth day shall be a time of restraint for you when you shall do no mundane work.” But the Torah puts the two words together: “Shemini Atzeres,” and that is what we call the Holiday.

Why a “Restraint?”

So why does the Torah call it a “restraint?”

By “restraint,” the Torah basically means a day of calm, of no milachah (physically creative activity as defined by the Torah, but which I have translated as “mundane work”), a day of self-restraint. But the meaning goes deeper than that.

Here is an important point that can help us understand why the Torah calls Shemini Atzeres a “restraint.” Besides the other Laws of the Holiday, we also had to sacrifice special offerings at the Holy Temple on each Holiday, and each one has its special offering, different than those of any other Holiday. On each day of Sukkos we brought sacrifices on behalf of the well-being of all the other nations of the world. A total of seventy sacrifices were brought just for the Gentile nations, over the course of the seven days of Sukkos. On the first day we offer 13 bulls, on the second day 12 bulls, the third day 11 bulls, and so on, until the seventh day, when seventy bulls have been brought on the altar. However, on Shemini Atzeres, the eighth day, we bring just one
bull, and that is for the nation of Israel.

The Rabbis tell us:

Why is the Holiday called “atzeres,” a restraint? It is like a king who proclaimed a festival for seven days. He invited all his subjects to attend the feast for all seven days. When the seven days ended, and everyone was to leave, the king told his son, “Stay with me just one more day, and we will celebrate together, just you and I.”

Likewise, when Sukkos ends, Hashem says, “I have “restrained” you, that is, I have held you back another day, after Sukkos has ended. All Sukkos you have offered seventy Sacrificial Offerings at the Holy Temple on behalf of the nations of the world. Today, bring just one offering, and that will be for just you and Me. Together, we will celebrate, just you and I.”

 – Rashi, Leviticus 23:36

Sukkos is a Holiday with several associations with the Gentile nations as well. But Shemini Atzeres is an additional day, an extra day during which the Jews celebrate their cherished relationship as the sons of Hashem.

In this way, Shemini Atzeres is different from the other Holidays. Sukkos, Passover, and
Shavuos, all celebrate miraculous events that Hashem did for us. Rosh Hashanah is the new year, during which Hashem “remembers” us (i.e., He judges us). Yom Kippur is the day we can be forgiven even our worst sins. Shemini Atzeres, however, celebrates our relationship with Hashem, and is not associated with any particular event.

Outside of Israel

Every Jewish Holiday except Yom Kippur has an extra day outside of the Land of Israel (though Rosh Hashanah has two days even in the Land of Israel). Therefore, any seven day Holiday, such as Passover, will actually have eight days when celebrated by people who live outside of Israel (even if they happen to temporarily be in Israel during that Holiday).

However, the extra day, the eight day for Sukkos falls out on Shemini Atzeres, which is a
Holiday of its own. Two Holidays are occurring on the same day! Therefore, we must assume some of the aspects of Sukkos, even as we observe the Holiday of Shemini Atzeres. So we eat in the Sukkah the night of Shemini Atzeres and the whole day of Shemini Atzeres. However, we do not make the Brachah (Blessing) that is normally made when eating in the Sukkah. Nor do we sleep in the Sukkah, nor do we use the Four Species during Shemini Atzeres.

Having said that, I must also add that many (particularly Chassidim) have the Custom not to eat in the Sukkah during Shemini Atzres. (Many great Rabbis have followed the Custom not to eat in the Sukkah during Shemini Atzeres, and we must respect that Custom with as great a reverence as we respect the Custom of those who eat in the Sukkah during Shemini Atzeres. If you have a doubt as to what to do, you should ask your Rabbi.)

Many who do not eat in the Sukkah during Shemini Atzeres have the Custom to say Kiddush in the Sukkah Shemini Atzeres during the day, and eat a little there (without saying the Brachah of “Sitting in the Sukkah,” of course). They then say a short prayer of farewell to the Mitzvah of sitting in the Sukkah, and they leave the Sukkah. The Holiday meal itself they eat in the house.

The second day of Shemini Atzeres, which is celebrated everywhere outside of Israel, is usually called Simchas Torah (Joy of the Torah), though in the prayers it is still called Shemini Atzeres.

One of the reasons we are so joyous on Shemini Atzeres is because during that Yom Tov we finish the yearly cycle of Weekly Torah Readings, and begin the cycle anew. We therefore rejoice and are very grateful for the Torah that Hashem has given us.

So on the first night of Shemini Atzeres, the second night, and the second day, it is the Custom to take all the Torah Scrolls out of the Ark and dance with them. Some people are given the honor to hold the Torah Scrolls and dance with them, and everyone else sings and dances in a circle or a line around them. This is done seven times, to represent the seven attributes with which Hashem manages and maintains the world (Chessed, Gevurah, etc., i.e., Kindness, Strength, etc.).

All the repentance and self-improvement we have been busy with for the past month and half culminates at this time. We begin with the declaration that Hashem is the G-d, and there is none other. We declare Hashem’s greatness. We ask Hashem to keep on helping us as we attempt to grow closer to Him. And then we rejoice over the Torah. And through that joy, we can merit a favorable judgment, because having joy for a Mitzvah has the power to annul a negative Heavenly decree.

Each and every Jew, no matter how great, and no matter how small he may think himself to be, is an equal inheritor to the Torah. The Torah says, “The Torah that Moses taught us is an inheritance to the Congregation of Jacob” (Deut. 33:4). We all have a right and a responsibility – like anyone who inherits a fortune — to the Torah. And we can all reap the benefits of that inheritance, if we avail ourselves of the Torah.